Which Two Small SUVs Did Consumer Reports Advise Shoppers to Skip?
If you’ve been browsing for a new small SUV, you’ve probably noticed that not all crossovers are created equal. In fact, some of the most popular models on the market don’t always live up to their reputations when it comes to reliability, safety, or owner satisfaction. According to recent findings from Consumer Reports, two small SUVs in particular have landed on the “skip it” list for 2024—and for reasons that might make you think twice before signing on the dotted line.
Why Did These Models Miss the Mark?
So, what’s holding these crossovers back? Consumer Reports bases its recommendations on a blend of road-test performance, predicted reliability, safety ratings, and feedback from thousands of real owners. For the two models in question, the biggest red flags were inconsistent reliability and a laundry list of owner complaints. Issues ranged from frequent trips to the mechanic for minor electrical gremlins to more serious concerns like transmission hiccups and infotainment systems that just wouldn’t cooperate.
One of the SUVs, despite its stylish looks and aggressive marketing, scored below average in predicted reliability for three years running. The other, while offering a comfortable ride, was dinged for lackluster fuel economy and a cramped rear seat—two factors that matter a lot to families and commuters alike.
What Do Owners Say About Living With These SUVs?
Numbers tell one story, but real-world experiences often fill in the gaps. Owners of these two crossovers reported frustrations that went beyond the occasional glitch. For example, several drivers mentioned that their vehicles spent more time at the dealership than in their own driveways during the first year of ownership. Others pointed out that promised tech features didn’t always work as advertised, leading to a sense of buyer’s remorse.
On the flip side, some owners did praise the SUVs for their nimble handling or eye-catching design. But when it comes to daily usability and peace of mind, the negatives seemed to outweigh the positives for a significant chunk of respondents.
How Do These Crossovers Compare to Top Picks in the Segment?
It’s not all doom and gloom in the small SUV world. Consumer Reports’ top-rated alternatives in this segment consistently deliver on reliability, safety, and owner satisfaction. For instance, models like the Mazda CX-5 and Honda CR-V have earned high marks for years, thanks to their well-rounded performance, comfortable interiors, and strong resale values. According to J.D. Power’s 2024 Vehicle Dependability Study, these models also rank above average in long-term reliability, which means fewer headaches down the road.
What Should Shoppers Look for Instead?
If you’re in the market for a small SUV, it pays to look beyond the badge and dig into the details. Focus on models with a proven track record for reliability, strong crash-test scores from the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS), and high owner satisfaction ratings. Don’t be afraid to test drive a few contenders back-to-back—sometimes the difference in comfort, visibility, or tech usability is only obvious when you’re behind the wheel.
And here’s a pro tip: check for any recent recalls or software updates before you buy. Even the best models can have an off year, but manufacturers that respond quickly to issues tend to keep their customers happier in the long run.
Is It Ever Worth Considering a Non-Recommended Model?
Sometimes, a deal on a non-recommended SUV can be tempting—especially if the price is right or you love the way it looks. But remember, lower upfront costs can be wiped out by higher maintenance bills or lower resale value down the line. If you’re set on a particular model, consider looking for a certified pre-owned version with an extended warranty. That way, you’ll have some extra peace of mind if things don’t go as planned.
The big takeaway? Choosing the right small SUV isn’t about perfection—it’s about smarter adjustments. Start with one change this week, like digging into owner reviews or scheduling a test drive with a top-rated alternative, and you’ll likely spot the difference by month’s end.
