Why Did the BMW E30 Lose Out to the Ford Taurus SHO and Sterling 827S?
If you’re a fan of classic sports sedans, the BMW E30 3 Series probably sits high on your list. Revered for its sharp handling and timeless design, it’s often the poster child for what a driver’s car should be. So, it might come as a shock to learn that in a major comparison test from the late 1980s, the E30 didn’t just lose to the Ford Taurus SHO—it also finished behind the little-remembered Sterling 827S. How did this happen? Let’s dig into what tipped the scales.
What Made the Ford Taurus SHO Stand Out Against European Rivals?
The Ford Taurus SHO was a bit of a curveball. On paper, it looked like a family sedan with a few sporty tweaks. Under the hood, though, Ford had teamed up with Yamaha to create a 3.0-liter V6 that revved like nothing else in its class. The result? Pure magic. The SHO churned out 220 horsepower—substantially more than the E30’s 168-horsepower inline-six. It wasn’t just about straight-line speed, either. The SHO’s chassis was surprisingly agile, and its steering felt alive in your hands.
Testers at the time were wowed by how the Taurus SHO combined everyday comfort with genuine performance. It had a roomy interior, a trunk that could swallow a week’s worth of groceries, and yet it could still hang with the best from Europe on a twisty road. In short, it was the sleeper hit nobody saw coming.
How Did the Sterling 827S Sneak Into the Winner’s Circle?
Now, the Sterling 827S is a name that rarely pops up in car conversations today. Back then, though, it was a British take on the Acura Legend, sharing much of its engineering with Honda’s luxury sedan. The Sterling brought a plush interior, a smooth V6, and a ride quality that felt more refined than most of its competitors. While it didn’t have the sporting pedigree of the BMW, it offered a level of comfort and equipment that appealed to buyers looking for a little more luxury in their daily drive.
Testers appreciated the Sterling’s balance between comfort and performance. It wasn’t the fastest, but it was composed and easy to live with. Sometimes, that’s enough to win hearts—especially when the competition is focused on outright sportiness at the expense of day-to-day usability.
Was the BMW E30 Overhyped, or Just Outgunned?
It’s tempting to chalk up the E30’s third-place finish to a fluke, but there’s more to the story. The E30 325i was (and still is) a brilliant driver’s car, but by the late 1980s, its formula was starting to show its age. The interior was tight, the ride could be harsh on rough roads, and its price tag was creeping up. Against fresher competition, the E30’s minimalist approach didn’t always translate to a better real-world experience.
Reviewers noted that while the E30 excelled on winding roads, it lagged behind in comfort and features. For buyers who wanted a car that could do it all—commute, road trip, and carve up a back road—the Taurus SHO and Sterling 827S simply offered more versatility.
What Do Modern Comparisons Tell Us About These Classic Sedans?
Looking back, it’s clear that the Taurus SHO and Sterling 827S were products of their time. The SHO, in particular, has gained a cult following for its blend of performance and practicality. The E30, meanwhile, has become a legend in its own right, with values skyrocketing as enthusiasts rediscover its charms.
Recent collector data from Hagerty shows E30 prices rising steadily, with well-kept examples fetching over $30,000. Meanwhile, the Taurus SHO and Sterling 827S have faded into obscurity, rarely seen at shows or on the road. It’s a reminder that what wins a comparison test in the moment doesn’t always stand the test of time.
What Can Today’s Drivers Learn from This Surprising Result?
If there’s a lesson here, it’s that greatness isn’t always obvious at first glance. The E30’s third-place finish didn’t diminish its legacy—it just highlighted how subjective car testing can be. Needs and tastes change, and what matters most to one driver might not move the needle for another.
The big takeaway? Chasing the perfect sports sedan isn’t about perfection—it’s about smarter adjustments. Start with one change this week, and you’ll likely spot the difference by month’s end. Sometimes, the underdog really does have the last laugh.
