Inside Billy Joel’s Real Car Collection: The Surprising Rides He Actually Owns

Did Billy Joel Really Trade a Chevy for a Cadillac?

Let’s clear up a rumor that’s been cruising around the internet for years: Billy Joel never swapped a Chevy for a Cadillac. Despite what you might have read on forums or seen in viral posts, this particular car trade is pure fiction. But here’s the twist—while the story isn’t true, the real-life car collection of Billy Joel is far more interesting than any urban legend.

What Kind of Cars Does Billy Joel Actually Own?

Billy Joel’s taste in cars is as eclectic as his music catalog. Forget the cliché of flashy supercars or endless rows of identical luxury sedans. Instead, his garage is a testament to genuine automotive passion. Over the years, Joel has owned everything from classic American muscle to quirky European imports. He’s especially fond of motorcycles and vintage rides that tell a story.

A few highlights from his collection? He’s been spotted with a 1967 Citroën DS, a car famous for its futuristic design and ahead-of-its-time suspension. There’s also his 1973 VW Beetle convertible—simple, iconic, and a nod to the everyman. And yes, he’s owned a few Chevys, but no record of a Cadillac trade-in.

Why Do These Car Myths Stick Around?

It’s easy to see why the Chevy-for-Cadillac tale gained traction. It fits the classic American dream narrative: trading up, moving on, making it big. But in reality, Joel’s approach to cars is less about status and more about nostalgia and craftsmanship. He once told an interviewer that he loves cars that have “soul”—machines that remind him of different chapters in his life.

The persistence of this myth also speaks to how stories about celebrities can take on a life of their own. A catchy lyric, a misunderstood quote, and suddenly the internet has a new “fact.” In Joel’s case, his song “Movin’ Out (Anthony’s Song)” mentions trading in a Chevy for a Cadillac, but that’s a character in the song—not Joel himself.

What Makes Billy Joel’s Collection Unusual?

Most celebrity garages are predictable: think Lamborghinis, Ferraris, and the occasional Rolls-Royce. Joel’s collection, on the other hand, is refreshingly unpredictable. He’s owned a Morgan, a rare British roadster, and a BSA motorcycle—both choices that show an appreciation for engineering over flash. He’s also a regular at classic car shows and has even opened his own motorcycle shop, 20th Century Cycles, in Oyster Bay, New York.

This hands-on approach is rare among celebrities. Joel doesn’t just collect cars; he drives them, works on them, and shares them with fellow enthusiasts. It’s a hobby rooted in genuine love, not just a desire to show off.

How Does Billy Joel’s Car Passion Influence His Life?

For Joel, cars aren’t just a hobby—they’re a way to connect with his past and unwind from the pressures of fame. He’s spoken about how working on engines helps him relax and sparks creativity. There’s a certain meditative quality to restoring a classic car or taking a long ride on a vintage motorcycle. It’s a reminder that even superstars need an escape, and for Joel, the open road is the perfect getaway.

What Can We Learn from Billy Joel’s Approach to Cars?

There’s a lesson here that goes beyond celebrity car collections. Joel’s story is a reminder to chase what genuinely excites you, not what looks good on paper or impresses strangers. Whether you’re into cars, music, or something else entirely, passion and authenticity always outshine status symbols.

The big takeaway? Chasing myths won’t get you far, but following your own interests—quirks and all—can lead to a collection (and a life) that’s truly one-of-a-kind. Start with one genuine pursuit this week, and you’ll likely spot the difference by month’s end.