Enterprising Hong Kongers find loopholes in new law

Hong Kong has declared protest slogans that call for the city's independence illegal under the new security law. Citizens have been arrested for holding up signs with these slogans, so they are now having to come up with creative alternatives.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Hong Kongers are finding creative ways to voice dissent after Beijing blanketed the city in a new security law and police began arresting people displaying now forbidden political slogans. People in Hong Kong are using creative ways to continue their slogans, which have now been banned by a new Chinese law. 

Faced with the sudden threat of prosecution for anything that might promote greater autonomy or independence for the restless city, residents are using word play and even subverting Chinese Communist Party dogma to express their frustration. 

Hong Kong citizens protest silently against Chinese law 

On a bridge in the busy shopping district of Causeway Bay, a key spot for pro-democracy protests over the past year, traffic thunders past newly daubed graffiti that declares: “Arise, ye who refuse to be slaves”. 

The phrase is taken from the first line of China’s national anthem. 

And while the graffiti could conceivably have been written by a patriotic nationalist, it is most likely a declaration of dissent.

Social media and chat forums have filled with suggestions for how to find safer ways to protest after Beijing on Tuesday imposed broad legislation banning subversion, secession, terrorism and foreign collusion.

Read more: Hong Kongers vanish from the internet amid new security law

In a semi-autonomous city used to speaking its mind, people will find ways around the law, said Chan Kin-man, a veteran democracy activist who has previously been jailed for his activism. 

“In a public space, one might either not say anything or use an ‘officially-approved’ language to protect themselves,” he told AFP. “But hidden language is something that cannot be banned by laws.”

Protest slogans declared illegal; citizens come up with creative alternatives 

The local government on Thursday said the popular protest slogan “Liberate Hong Kong, revolution of our times” would now be deemed illegal.

For some the phrase represents genuine aspirations to split Hong Kong from China, a red line for Beijing, but for many others it is a more general cry for democracy and an expression of rising frustration with Chinese rule.

But coded language is allowing people to keep the slogan alive.

One version “GFHG, SDGM” uses English letters from the transliterated phrase “gwong fuk heung gong, si doi gak ming”.

Another more complex example mimics the tone and rhythm of the slogan using the numbers “3219 0246” in Cantonese. 

Chinese characters themselves also provide ample room for linguistic subversion. 

Read more: China one-ups the West by passing Hong Kong law

One phrase people have started adopting online is “seize back banana”, a play on the similar characters in traditional Chinese for Hong Kong and banana.  

Others have gone for English slogans that appear positive but are a clear dig at Beijing — for example the Trumpian phrase “Make Hong Kong Great”.

The very first arrest made under the new security law involved a deliberate linguistic challenge. 

During protests a day after the law was enacted, police announced they had arrested a man with a flag that read “Hong Kong Independence”, posting a picture.

But eagle-eyed web sleuths zoomed in on the flag and spotted that a man had written a small “No” before his much larger phrase. 

The same phrase has since gone viral online. 

Police cracking down on protest slogans in Hong Kong 

The national security law has already had a chilling effect on speech in Hong Kong, which was guaranteed “freedom of speech, the press, assembly, association, procession and demonstration” before the former British colony’s return to Chinese rule in 1997. Several high-profile pro-democracy activists have dissolved groups or attempted to leave the city in recent days, and the U.S. and U.K. have accused Beijing of violating its promise to maintain the city’s “high degree of autonomy” for 50 years.

Multiple pro-democracy restaurants and shops across the city have taken down their “Lennon Wall” displays expressing support for the pro-democracy movement after some were warned by police that they might violate the national security law. 

The walls are often made up of colourful sticky notes with protest slogans on them.

One cafe replaced its wall with blank memos. 

“What is essential is invisible to the eyes,” the shop wrote on its Facebook citing popular children’s book “Le Petit Prince”. 

Another symbol of defiance that has replaced some protest art across the city is blank white pages.

The gesture represents the inability to speak out and also “white terror”, a Chinese phrase used to describe political persecution.

“Suppression catalyses people to fight back,” said Chan, who is also a sociology professor.

He likened the situation with how people in mainland China reveal dissent or anger towards the government with a wink and a nod.

“Hong Kong people will definitely respond more actively, it’s just that it might happen in a grey area”.

A slogan that went viral this week was a quote by Chinese dictator Mao Zedong. 

It read: “Those who suppress the student movements will not come to a good end.” 

AFP with additional input by GVS News Desk

Will they manage to evade the law? Share with us in the comments bar below.