Home Opinion Op-Ed Is it time for Israel-Pakistan potential talks? – Jan Achakzai

Is it time for Israel-Pakistan potential talks? – Jan Achakzai

Israel
  • 1.2K
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
    1.2K
    Shares

Jan Achakzai |

Israeli Prime Minister’s visit to Oman, the tiny Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) country and meeting the Sultan of Oman, Sayyid Qaboos bin Said Al Said, is unprecedented. Sultan of Oman is a statesman who has played a mediatory role in other hot spots in the past and recently also met a Palestinian leadership.

Earlier, there were rumors that Israeli Prime Minister went to Pakistan which have not been officially acknowledged as Pakistan’s Foreign Office does not comment on media reports.

Definitely, Israeli PM had not gone to Oman on a recreational trip, nor it could be against Iran given Muscat has balanced ties with Tehran while equally friendly with other GCC countries, just like Pakistan enjoying balanced relations with both rivals (I.e., Saudi Arabia and Iran).

Pakistan starts working to bridge gaps and establishing a working relationship with Israel so India does not leverage Tel Aviv against Islamabad.

Israeli PM is keen to find a solution to the Palestinian issue, after all, only a hardline Israeli PM has a genuine chance to make peace with Palestinians. Changing landscape of the Middle East also makes things different for old foes and friends. With Muhammad Bin Salman (called MBS) practically heading the leading country of GCC, Saudi Arabia, a pragmatic leadership is emerging in the Middle East as well.

The larger context is changing: Israel is increasingly expanding its reach to Asia as it focuses on economies of the region following the decline in EU markets and declining US economy relative to Asia.

Asia from China to the Middle East to Iran is attractive for Israel in many ways. It has turned itself into a confluence of big data, AI & biotechnology to connect with other emerging markets; it has developed modern agricultural expertise exporting to Asian/Indian to African farmers and its selling deference and surveillance capabilities.

Read more: Five questions on Israel’s controversial Jewish nation law

But should Pakistan and Israel establish some engagement as Tel Aviv is expanding its footprints not only in the Muslim world but also in India?

Israel-India Nexus
  1. Israel and India have flourished ties. For Pakistan, they converge on Kashmir & Palestine-genocide, demographic changes, and ghettoization as common policy by the two states.
  2. India has got access to Jewish Cartels, investment, and media, and enhanced its security, Intel and 4th generational war capabilities. Increased convergence of US, India, and Israel as a tripartite alliance further squeezes space for Pakistan in Anglo- Saxon World and far beyond
  3. Saudis and other GCC countries have established working relations with Israel as a strong geopolitical reality.
Baluchistan

How much Baloch insurgents (in exile) are keen to court Israelis and get to their intelligence, can be gauged by their desperate attempts from getting membership of Freemasons to planting Op-eds in Israeli papers, to interacting with their diplomats.

Pakistan needs a political will to prepare the nation and take bold initiative on this behalf if it gets a reasonable quid pro quo in bilateral relations with Israel.

Baluchistan is on Israeli radar for many reasons. Baluchistan is in the neighborhood of Iran providing easy access to human intel on Iran through its “Non-conventional intel collectors” comprising mostly ethnic Baloch separatists and some ethnic sub-nationalist Pashtun expatriates; If the next probable Trump administration decides on “Regime Collapse” in Iran strategy, Baluchistan will be zoomed to turn into logistical and intel hub for Israel (not a far-fetched idea as many would believe); and Israel believes Pakistan, as a state and society is anti-Zionist state so, is a peripheral threat to its interests.

Since Pakistan’s many levers on the US are waning, Islamabad’s only bridge to Washington is apparently KSA which only ‘buys’ influence with DC (and may run out of money someday), so is fragile and hostage to whims of the administration’s hawks and may not function according to Islamabad’s liking in managing relations with unpredictable sole superpower.

Read more: Should Pakistan ‘establish contacts’ with Israel just like KSA?

The major benefit Pakistan can derive from normal relations with Israel is to capitalize Tel Aviv’s leverage with the US, apart from cooperation in defense and trade including IT, AI and agriculture and neutralizing the effects of strong converge between Israel and India.

Scenario 1): Islamabad continues to ignore Israel and its rising clout: expansion in China, India, Far East, Middle East, and CA, from opening new Consulates to defense cooperation and economic exchanges to developing linguistic skills in Chinese, Persian, and Pashto etc.

(Note: Palestinian issue has gone into the background in these regions, though not in Pakistan).

Saudis and other GCC countries have established working relations with Israel as a strong geopolitical reality.

Scenario 2): Pakistan starts working to bridge gaps and establishing a working relationship with Israel so India does not leverage Tel Aviv against Islamabad. Islamabad can go public if it gets some sort of assurance statement on Palestinians.

Yes, Rightwing groups will exploit this issue but does Pakistan ignore tectonic geopolitical shifts because fringe groups demand irrational state behaviors in dealing with foreign policy imperatives, from a nuclear state living in a dangerous geopolitical neighborhood?

Read more: Israel furious as Argentina cancels match, while Palestinians celebrate Messi

Pakistan needs a political will to prepare the nation and take bold initiative on this behalf if it gets a reasonable quid pro quo in bilateral relations with Israel.

Jan Achakzai is a geopolitical analyst and a politician. He served as an advisor to previous Balochistan Government on media and strategic communication. He remained associated with BBC World Service in London covering South and West Asia. The views expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect Global Village Space’s editorial policy.


  • 1.2K
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
    1.2K
    Shares

7 COMMENTS

  1. That is a very low quality article, devoid of any critical analysis. It seems that the entire article is politically motivated tries to push an agenda. The idea that establishing relationship with Israel will improve relationship with USA is ridiculous and nonsensical, and exposes the shallowness of the author’s level of intellect.

    Such low quality article do great disservice to you publication and brings discredit to it.

    Asad Faizi

  2. Agreed with Asad Faizi.It is substandard article just meant to launch an agenda, knowingly that will of ppl of pakistan can not b changed in absence of settlement of phlastine issue on Pre 1967 status.in this connection some hints have been pointed at to frighten Pakistan. Israel if has sincere desire to establish relations on firm footing with islsmic world ist it must normalise its relations with plastinian on UNSC resolution on the subject based on 2 nations theory. That will provide a lasting solution of the core issue, it is confronting since her very inception.

  3. Let them first return all the settlements and return to 67 borders and then not just us but the whole region will be ready for them. Empty words and promises are not enough.

  4. if Israel get on a solution for Palestine then what is wrong with accepting Israel as a country, or just make a conditional acceptance for their help on Kashmir issue

  5. Israel can’t return back to the position of 1967 rather she has taken a step further to shift her capital to Al Quds. This is a sheer compulsion for the Zionists: being Jews, by faith. To further facilitate their Saviour’s earlier physical appearance on Jews’ land, they need to create a ‘greater Israel’. This is yet another faith-compulsion for Israelites. Israel is one ideological state on the face of Earth; Pakistan is another. Despite being ideologically closer to each other (both Muslims & Jews believe in monotheism of God; they both have other religious practices in common as well), yet it isn’t clear as to what has created such a gap between the two Abrahimic believers?
    May be the geographic situation of Pakistan (lying in the East of Madina) is one reason; Armageddon the second !!

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.