As Germany underwent its Universal Periodic Review (UPR) at the United Nations in Geneva, the spotlight was intensified by the ongoing Gaza crisis. While Germany received broad praise for its robust human rights record, especially on the 85th anniversary of Kristallnacht, criticism from mainly Muslim countries regarding its stance on Israeli atrocities in Gaza could not be ignored.
Praise for Germany’s Human Rights Record
Germany’s commitment to human rights was widely acknowledged during the UPR. The country’s efforts in promoting and protecting human rights were commended by various representatives. The 85th anniversary of Kristallnacht, a grim reminder of the Holocaust, added a solemn backdrop to the discussion on human rights, emphasizing the importance of preventing atrocities and ensuring the protection of vulnerable populations.
Read More: Israeli flags burned across Germany
Unusual Levels of Criticism
However, the review was not without its challenges. Representatives from mainly Muslim countries expressed discontent with Germany’s perceived support for Israel and its restrictions on pro-Palestinian protests. Egypt’s representative, Ahmed Moharam, voiced deep regret over Germany’s positions on the rights of the Palestinian people, and Jordan criticized what it saw as unbalanced stances taken by Germany.
Turkiye’s Call to Halt Military Support for Israel
Turkiye took a bold stance, urging Germany to cease providing any military material or equipment to Israel that could be used in the commission of war crimes and crimes against humanity. This call highlighted the complexities of international relations, especially concerning conflicts in the Middle East, and challenged Germany to reassess its position on military support.
Germany’s Defense of Israel’s Right to Exist
In response to the criticisms, Germany reiterated its support for Israel’s right to defend itself. Luise Amtsberg, the commissioner for human rights policy and humanitarian assistance, emphasized that Israel’s security and right to exist are non-negotiable for Germany. Amtsberg’s statements reflected the delicate balance Germany seeks to maintain in navigating international relations, particularly in the context of the Gaza crisis.
Kristallnacht Commemoration and Rising Anti-Semitism
The timing of the UPR, coinciding with the anniversary of Kristallnacht, added a poignant layer to the discussions. Amtsberg highlighted Germany’s commitment to ‘never again’ and expressed concern over the rise in anti-Semitic acts in the past month. The protection of Jewish life was deemed non-negotiable, reflecting Germany’s commitment to learning from its dark history and preventing the recurrence of atrocities.
Addressing Concerns for Civilian Populations in Gaza
While emphasizing its support for Israel, Germany acknowledged the legitimate concerns about the civilian population in Gaza and the Palestinian territories. Amtsberg acknowledged that people in Germany are justifiably worried about the impact of the conflict on innocent lives. This acknowledgment showcased Germany’s commitment to a nuanced approach that considers the well-being of all affected populations.
The UN’s review of Germany’s human rights record amid the Gaza crisis brought to light the complexities of navigating international relations, particularly in the Middle East. Germany’s commitment to human rights, its defense of Israel’s right to exist, and acknowledgment of concerns for civilian populations in Gaza reflect the delicate balance the country seeks to maintain. As the international community grapples with the ongoing challenges, Germany’s approach serves as a reminder of the intricate diplomacy required to address human rights issues in a global context.