Europe needs its industrial companies to save energy amid soaring costs and shrinking supplies, and they are delivering – demand for natural gas and electricity both fell in the past quarter.
It is far too early to rejoice, though. The drop is not just because industrial companies are turning down thermostats, they are also shutting down plants that may never reopen.
And while lower energy use helps Europe weather the crisis sparked by Russia’s war in Ukraine and Moscow’s supply cuts, executives, economists and industry groups warn its industrial base may end up severely weakened if high energy costs persist.
Energy-intensive industries, such as aluminium, fertilisers, and chemicals are at risk of companies permanently shifting production to locations where cheap energy abounds, such as the United States.
Even as an unusually warm October and projections of a mild winter helped drive prices lower, natural gas in the United States still costs about a fifth what companies pay in Europe.
“A lot of companies are just quitting production,” Patrick Lammers, management board member at utility E.ON (EONGn.DE) told a conference in London last month. “They actually demand destruct.”
The International Energy Agency estimates European industrial gas demand fell by 25% in the third quarter from a year earlier. Analysts say widespread shutdowns had to be behind the drop because efficiency gains alone would not produce such savings.
We model potential European energy crises. "To understand how the energy war might develop, The Economist has worked with modellers at Rystad Energy, a consultancy. Our analysis suggests that complacency is dangerous. Things could get very bad, very fast." https://t.co/Bzag7YMQPw
— Shashank Joshi (@shashj) November 1, 2022
But when the weather turns colder and households crank up heating, the industrial sector will be the first to face cuts in case of shortages, economists warn.
European industry has been shifting production to locations with cheaper labour and lower other costs for decades, but the energy crisis is accelerating the exodus, analysts said.
“If the energy prices stay so elevated that part of European industry becomes structurally uncompetitive, factories will shut down and move to the U.S. where there is an abundance of cheap shale energy,” said Daniel Kral, senior economist at Oxford Economics.
For example, EU primary aluminium output was halved, cut by 1 million tonnes, over the past year.
Trade figures compiled by Reuters show all nine zinc smelters in the bloc have either cut or stopped production, which was replaced by imports from China, Kazakhstan, Turkey, and Russia.
Reopening an aluminium smelter costs up to 400 million euros ($394 million) and is unlikely given Europe’s uncertain economic outlook, Chris Heron at industry association Eurometaux said.
“Historically, when these temporary closures happen, permanent closures come as a consequence,” he added.
Western efforts to secure supplies not just for energy but also for key minerals used in electric vehicles and renewable infrastructure are also at risk from high energy prices.
Read more: Is Europe shifting back to coal energy
Brussels is expected to propose new legislation early next year – the European Critical Raw Materials Act – to build up reserves of minerals indispensable in the transition to green economy, such as lithium, bauxite, nickel, and rare earths.
But without more renewable power and lower costs, companies are unlikely to invest in Europe, Emanuele Manigrassi, climate and energy senior manager at European Aluminium, warned.
The feared industrial erosion is already underway. Europe became a net importer of chemicals for the first time ever this year, according to Cefic, the European Chemical Industry Council.
More than half of European ammonia production, a key ingredient in fertilisers, has shut, and has been replaced by imports, according to the International Fertilizer Association.
Norwegian fertiliser maker Yara (YAR.OL) has cut two-thirds of its European ammonia production and has no immediate plans to ramp it back up.
“We are watching the situation in the gas market closely and are making contingency plans,” CEO Svein Tore Holsether told Reuters via email.
Last week, the world’s largest chemical group BASF (BASFn.DE) questioned whether there was a business case for new plants in Europe.
The company has also warned it would have to shut production at its main Ludwigshafen site – Germany’s single-biggest industrial power consumer – if gas supplies fall below half of its needs.
Read more: Energy crisis set to worsen
Some firms, including German viscose fibre maker Kelheim Fibres which supplies Procter & Gamble (PG.N), are looking to other energy sources. This year, the German company has cut output twice at its factory in Bavaria.
“From Jan. 1, we will be able to switch to oil,” company executive Wolfgang Ott said, as the company seeks government help to cushion energy costs. It is even pondering a 2 megawatt solar project.
German industries have been seeking speedier approvals to switch from gas to more polluting fuels, warning that otherwise they would be forced to cut production to meet Berlin’s savings targets.
In Greece, Selected Textiles, a small cotton yarn producer, has cut output as orders mainly from northern Europe have fallen.
Read more: Energy prices soar in 2021
At its plant in Farsala, central Greece, CEO Apostolos Dontas estimated production would fall 30% this year.
“We see our clients (…) are seriously concerned whether there will be an equivalent consumption of finished products in Europe and whether northern European manufacturers themselves will have access to natural gas,” he told Reuters.
Tata Chemicals (TTCH.NS), which usually operates on a five-year plan, is now working on a quarterly basis, its Europe managing director Martin Ashcroft said.
“If this is a structural change and gas prices stay high for three or four years, the real risk is industry investment will be directed elsewhere to places with lower energy prices,” Ashcroft added.
Reuters story with additional input by Global Village Space news desk.