Kulbhushan
Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Abdul Rahim |

Pakistan and India, since the time of their separation, have been countering each other both at diplomatic and security levels with the aim to subvert each other’s interests. Throughout these 70 years, the ball of disagreement has been seen bouncing continuously on the court of controversies laid down between these two neighbors. Global powers like Russia and the US have always fished in the troubled water.

In recent years, India’s involvement in Pakistan has increased to a whole new level. The killing of Akbar Bugti in 2006, initiation of CPEC, construction of Gwadar port, and insurgency in Afghanistan provided grounds for Indian intelligence agency RAW (Research and Analysis Wing) to sabotage Pakistan’s internal security situation.

Read more: India & Pakistan: Narratives of the ‘Evil Neighbor’ a threat to peace

Provision of hidden support to Baloch rebels, funding to Tehreek e Taliban Pakistan in FATA, terrorist activities in the country, and the old blame-game policy are the few vivid acts played by India to undermine Pakistan internally.

One of the best proofs of India’s hand in Pakistan’s affairs is the arrest of an in-service Indian naval officer, Kulbhushan Yadav. Mr. Yadav, after his arrest, admitted his involvement in killing masses in terrorist activities and the support of anti-state agenda in Baluchistan to de-stabilize Pakistan. The arrest of Kulbhushan revealed India’s designs for Pakistan to fuel Baloch insurgency, ultimately leading to failure of CPEC and Gwadar port.

Kulbhushan Yadav’s death sentence 

This death sentence will kill this game, giving India an opportunity to start afresh, rebuilding her trust and position through diplomacy.

Pakistan’s military court sentenced RAW agent Kulbhushan Yadav to death. Pakistan’s decision can add more fuel to the already deteriorated relations between the two countries. RAW will surely try to unearth, and then counter, ISI’s tricky game which led to the failure of Indian’s well sought out plan against Pakistan.

Though the decision is cent-per-cent legal according to the constitution of Pakistan, it was, maybe, not the best time to make it. This step will allow India to structure new strategies and plans to counter Pakistan.

Read more: Clerics return! Indian allegations & “Pakistan Phobia” gone wrong once again?

The killing of Akbar Bugti in 2006, initiation of CPEC, construction of Gwadar port, and insurgency in Afghanistan provided grounds for Indian intelligence agency RAW to sabotage Pakistan’s internal security situation.

Under Pakistan’s custody, Kulbhushan was a serious threat to India’s position at international level. This death sentence will kill this game, giving India an opportunity to start afresh, rebuilding her trust and position through diplomacy. Pakistan, instead of sentencing him to death, should have utilized the ‘Kulbhushan card’ against India both on regional and international levels.

One of the counter-strategies by RAW might be linked with the recent missing of retired Pak Army officer, Lt. Col. Habib Zahir. Habib Zahir was in Nepal for a job interview, from where he went missing. India will now try to portray him as an ISI agent arrested by Indian security agencies near the bordering area with Nepal. Indian media will extend every possible support to RAW in order to paint a bad picture of Pakistan in front of the international community.

Pakistan should have extended this card from three to four years with full-time active smart diplomacy and blame-game strategy both at regional and global levels.

Disclosing the arrest of Kulbhushan on the arrival of Iranian President was a futile act that led to an environment of mistrust and suspicion between Pakistan and Iran. This act of Pakistan provided India another opportunity to come closer to Iran. In other words, we lost Iran both at political and economic levels. In response to Pakistan, Iran stretched a friendly hand towards India. In other words, Pakistan secured nothing from Kulbhushan Yadav story but only pushed Iran towards India.

Read more: How serious is India about restoring connections with Pakistan?

The death sentence to Kulbhushan after a short trial will prove useless. Liquidating Indian agent within a year is unwise. Pakistan should have extended this card from three to four years with full-time active smart diplomacy and blame-game strategy both at regional and global levels. In result, it would have helped Pakistan to re-establish his deteriorated status at the global level which is greatly caricatured by India.

Job-lookup story of missing Pak army retired officer

Indian newspaper ‘Times of India’ (TOM) has intentionally mentioned Kulbhushan Yadav as a ‘retired’ Indian Navy officer in order to balance the game against Pakistan, as the missing Lieutenant Colonel Habib Zahir is also a retired officer in Pak army.

Pakistan must take the issue of missing ‘retired’ officer at a higher level in order to make the regional states cognizant about the situation.

The ‘job-lookup story’ of the missing Lieutenant Colonel is in itself a disgraceful story for Pakistan and Pakistan Army. In such critical security situation where Pakistani security agencies are seriously facing challenges both at regional and global levels, the lustful nature of retired army officers to go abroad for jobs is shameful and disgusting.

Read more: Are Indians and Pakistanis on the same page when they talk of draining the swamp of terrorism?

Yet, the game is in Pakistan’s hands. Any further mistakes or unwise steps can lead to losing regional and global influences. Pakistan must take the issue of missing ‘retired’ officer at a higher level in order to make the regional states cognizant about the situation.

Pakistan media should help the security agencies and government to present the case of Habib Zahir in front of international community. It will help Pakistan to dissuade India from possible blame-game against Pakistan. In result, India will not be able to secure a new card at both diplomatic and political levels.

Abdul Rahim has completed his M. Phil degree with a focus on foreign policies, regional security, and strategic affairs at International Islamic University, Islamabad. The views expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect Global Village Space’s editorial policy.

Abdul Rahim has completed his M. Phil degree with a focus on foreign policies, regional security, and strategic affairs at International Islamic University, Islamabad.

8 COMMENTS

  1. How much money have you got from RAW for writing this article. India would have done the same. Pakistan needs to create DOT BUSTER GROUPS in the gulf countries. This will destroy India’s foreign exchange balance, in fact the whole economy.

  2. Partially correct but the theme is flawed and does not reflect the experience of Rahim. I would say it is based on bookish knowledge . In strategic parlance death sentence is a correct message.
    Any one who understands pschy of Hindu mind understan this there was no better person than Jinnah who in 1938 Muslim League All India address warned the horrors of perpetual Hindu Raj .
    Kulbasan has no value for India except exploitation.

    The weakness of state is invitation for destruction.

  3. Firstly, the reader must read between the lines in order to understand Rahim’s article. He is preferring to Neo – realist approach towards understanding strategic affairs.
    The article is based on logical grounds. Pakistan should have used this card against India. Emotionalism, India – centrist mentalities and crazy nature of revenge are third-level terms. Diplomacy, smart policy and securing strategic interests needs passion and long-term policies. Local approach towards resolving critical issues will led to no where. Though the decision is correct (as Rahim has also mentioned) but the time is not suitable. Before awarding death sentence, Pakistan should have used it as card against Modi sarkar for two or three years.

  4. This is how you might perceive Yadev’s death sentence. Yadev’s death sentence have put enormous pressure on India and its intel agency RAW. They have been pushed back and their whole game plane was disclosed. It will take too much time to rethink another strategy and even prepare their agents to come to Pak. They are completely in panic and they are just shouting. The only thing we could have done better was to propagate Yadevs issue internationally which is a worst failure of Nawaz Sharif a puppet of India. Until we remove Nawaz and Zardari India will have their agents in Pakistan easily. Otherwise they cant counter ISI’s game plan. Its our elected bastards who leak security meetings from PM house and they are still sitting there. Its time to throw them out and its been decided they will be thrown out but

  5. As you said he is an in-service naval personal. Name one country that will send an in service army/navy/air force personnel as a spy along with his own country’s passport. And why would any country send an in service personnel to carry out terrorist activities in another country. All over the world spies are non combatants and have different skill sets. Also, unwritten rule in the spy world is that no Govt. will accept a spy as their own. Give one instance where Pakistani spies are caught and Pakistan has owned them up. And BTW, no country will believe if you go and say to the world that we caught an Indian Navy personal with Indian passport doing terrorism in Pakistan.
    The only thing good about this article is its heading. Pakistan has really pushed a self destruct button not now but long time back. It is slowly going into oblivion. Wait and watch.

Comments & Discussion