self-righteous elite
Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Imtiaz Gul |

An outpouring of condemnation and protests have been seen on the media after the lynching of the 23-year-old Mashal Khan by a raging and feckless mob at the Abdul Wali Khan University, Mardan; including protestations and warnings by the ruling elites – from the prime minister to the chief justice of the Supreme Court. Quite understandable.

PTI Chairman Imran Khan took the lead in condemning those involved “the law of the jungle can’t prevail.” The Prime Minster Sharif took the initiative after 36 hours and rejected “the idea of self-imposed vigilantes and directed action against those found involved in the incident”, and ordered the police to arrest all those who were responsible.

Read more: Mashal Khan’s murder & Pakistan’s religious cauldron: dark shadow of General Zia

“Let it be known to the perpetrators of this act that the state shall not tolerate citizens taking the law into their own hands.”
– Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif

In a press statement, PPP Chairperson Bilawal Bhutto Zardari said such incidents in universities were a big threat to educational institutions and that the government should take adequate steps to check such incidents in future.

PPP Senator Sherry Rehman was moved by Mashal’s father’s speech on TV and questioned the federal government on maintaining silence over the incident.

Bakhtawar Bhutto, daughter of PPP Co-Chairman Asif Ali Zardari, hoped that the accused are tried for murder, saying “no one has the right to take a life. Hope the students and police involved are treated like the murderers they are”.

Some federal ministers including Nisar Ali Khan, Khurram Dastgir, and Khawaja Asif, too, denounced Mashal’s lynching.

Read more: Pakistan, India amongst top countries of the world in religious restrictions

Chief Justice of Pakistan Justice Mian Saqib Nisar, too, joined the bandwagon 48 hours later and instructed the inspector general police of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa to submit a report on the incident in the next 36 hours.

If the chief justice is interested in taking Mashal’s killers task, he and his colleagues should ideally work to rid Pakistan of the obsolete and oppressive Pakistan Penal Code and Criminal Procedures Code.

Mufti Naeem, head of Jamia Binoria, also stepped forward in urging ulema from all sects in the country to unanimously condemn acts of violence originating from the misuse of the blasphemy law. He urged religious scholars to declare “killing an individual over blasphemy allegations against the Shariah as well as the law of Pakistan”.

Do these comments hold meaning?

All these comments resonate sympathy and anger but let us pause for a while. Isn’t this a moment of introspection for these elites?

Shouldn’t they hold themselves and their petty short political interests responsible for this abhorrible act? Haven’t most of them been pandering to the religious right for their petty electoral interests?

They have in fact little to offer in defense of their political posturing.

Read more: Blood and Mayhem: The true face of a blind impotent society

Unless our leading lights – the ruling elites – turn these words into a narrative by reforming governance, the criminal justice system, cleansing the curricula of hate materials, and until they commit to and work for protecting every single citizen of Pakistan, their lofty rhetoric will remain meaningless.

If Nawaz Sharif wants the people to believe in his aforementioned warning to the “perpetrators” then he himself should start applying the rule of law to his family and the party.

If the chief justice is interested in taking Mashal’s killers task, he and his colleagues should ideally work to rid Pakistan of the obsolete and oppressive Pakistan Penal Code and Criminal Procedures Code to make justice delivery easy, inexpensive, and quicker.

Through an urgent comprehensive review of the criminal justice system, the honorable judges will do the entire nation a big favor instead of fishing for individual cases such as the one under discussion.

They have to ensure quick justice delivery and the certainty of punishment if they want the bulging youth of Pakistan not to lose hope in the state and the promises coming from the ruling elites and the judiciary.

One would hope that these self-righteous and ever-pontificating elites would heed to the passionate message by Iqbal Jan, the father of Mashal Khan.

Read more: The twist and turns of the Blasphemy law in Pakistan

“In every house, there is a mashal (torch) of education. We as Muslims should be respected and those who are not Muslims should also be respected. These are the things they should include in the curriculum.”
– Iqbal Jan

Unless our leading lights – the ruling elites – turn these words into a narrative by reforming governance, the criminal justice system, cleansing the curricula of hate materials, and until they commit to and work for protecting every single citizen of Pakistan, their lofty rhetoric will remain meaningless. And the directionless, disbelieving and frustrated youth will keep slipping into intolerance.

Imtiaz Gul is the founder and Executive Director of the Centre for Research and Security Studies (CRSS), an Islamabad-based think tank. He is the author of Pakistan: Pivot of Hizbut Tahrir’s Global Caliphate. This article was originally published in Daily Times and has been republished with permission. The views expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect Global Village Space’s editorial policy.

Imtiaz Gul is the founder and Executive Director of Center for Research and Security Studies, an Islamabad-based think tank that he founded in December 2007. He is a prominent columnist and author of several books on South Asia including “Pakistan: Before & After Osama Bin Laden”. He regularly appears as an analyst on Pakistani TV channels as well as the Doha-based Al-Jazeera English/Arabic satellite TV channel for his expertise in areas such as Afghanistan/Tribal Areas / and the Kashmir militancy. He is a prominent columnist writing for the Express Tribune, Daily Times, Foreign Policy and many others. He is the author of several books on South Asia, his latest book “Pakistan: Before & After Osama Bin Laden”. He regularly appears as an analyst on Pakistani TV channels as well as the Doha-based Al-Jazeera English/Arabic satellite TV channel for his expertise in areas such as Afghanistan/Tribal Areas / and the Kashmir militancy. He has presented papers and given talks at universities and international security and counter-terror conferences in Brussels, Tokyo, Berlin, New Delhi, Kabul, New York, Washington, the Hague, Riyadh, Italy, Oslo, Stockholm, Beijing. http://www.imtiazgul.com/

Comments & Discussion